Butterfinger Pie | Cookies and Cups

This Butterfinger Pie is a straightforward dessert that’s loaded with Butterfinger sweet bars and silky, creamy no-bake pie filling. Deal with your self and the household to a slice of indulgent chocolate peanut butter pie!

Do you’re keen on Butterfinger sweet and no-bake desserts? Strive my No-Bake Butterfinger Caramel Bars, too!

Butterfinger pie garnished with whipped cream and chopped Butterfinger candy bars.
Butterfinger Pie | Cookies and Cups 48

The Final Pie for Peanut Butter Lovers

Aren’t Butterfinger bars the most effective? Ask any peanut butter lover. All these layers of peanut butter crisp swaddled in milky chocolate. It’s a dream.

Have you learnt what’s even higher than a single Butterfinger bar? A complete lot of them. Piled into this Butterfinger PIE!

My Butterfinger pie recipe is a basic (virtually) no-bake dessert. This riff on sweet pie makes use of my Best Graham Cracker Pie Crust, crammed to the brim with a silky-smooth Butterfinger cream filling.

This peanut butter pie is wealthy and decadent, but unbelievably gentle and fluffy. It’s full of sweet bar crunch and tons of peanut butter taste. No surprise it disappears from the pie plate virtually as quick as I can serve it!

The ingredients for Butterfinger pie.
Butterfinger Pie | Cookies and Cups 49

What You’ll Want

Right here you’ll discover all the things you must make your individual Butterfinger pie! You’ll want to scroll additional right down to the recipe card for the total ingredient quantities: 

For the Graham Cracker Crust

  • Graham Crackers: Use graham cracker crumbs, or crush up full graham cracker sheets to make the bottom for this easy pie crust.
  • Butter: Salted or unsalted, and melted.
  • Salt
  • Sugar

For the Pie Filling

  • Cream Cheese: Use the cream cheese that is available in blocks and never the spreadable tub variety! For a {smooth} filling (and likewise for simpler mixing), take your cream cheese out of the fridge and let it come to room temperature.
  • Creamy Peanut Butter: Your favourite model of creamy peanut butter, like Jif or Skippy. Be sure to’re utilizing the creamy variety for the creamiest outcomes! See beneath.
  • Powdered Sugar: You might also realize it as confectioner’s sugar. This sweetens up the pie filling whereas the nice consistency retains the feel {smooth}.
  • Butterfinger Sweet: I exploit the fun-sized model, however you may additionally use full-sized Butterfingers, as you’ll be chopping them up anyway.
  • Cool Whip: For the final word fluff issue! Thaw out an 8 oz. tub of Cool Whip.

For the Garnish

  • Whipping Cream: Use chilly heavy whipping cream. To get the feel excellent, depart it chilled proper up till you utilize it. For finest outcomes, chill the bowl you’ll use for whipping, too!
  • Powdered Sugar
  • (Extra) Butterfinger Sweet

What Sort of Peanut Butter is Finest?

You’ll wish to keep on with the shelf-stable, creamy number of peanut butter for this recipe. I positively don’t advocate pure peanut butter for Butterfinger pie. The surplus oils in pure peanut butter can mess with the feel and trigger issues to separate. We’re after silky {smooth}, mousse-like pie filling right here, buddies!

The ingredients for the graham cracker crust.
Butterfinger Pie | Cookies and Cups 50

Find out how to Make Butterfinger Pie

Selfmade Butterfinger pie is a 3-step surprise! It’s mainly a matter of crust, pie filling, and garnish. The result’s an actual showstopper that you could have prepared with minimal prep and a little bit of chilling time:

Make the Crust: Get that oven preheated to 350°F. In the meantime, combine your graham cracker crumbs, butter, sugar, and salt collectively in a bowl. Press the crust combination right into a 9-inch pie plate, then bake till golden. You’ll must let your crust cool utterly earlier than you assemble the pie.

Put together the Filling: Is that crust good and funky? Good! Subsequent, you’ll beat collectively the cream cheese, peanut butter, and powdered sugar. Fold in your chopped Butterfingers, adopted by the Cool Whip.

Assemble: Plop the filling into your cooled crust and unfold it evenly inside. Place the pie into the fridge to relax for a minimum of 2 hours.

Garnish: As soon as the pie is chilled, you’ll be able to serve it as is, however I favor to pile on the garnish. Prime your Butterfinger pie with further Cool Whip or whipped cream, plus much more chopped Butterfinger sweet.

A slice of Butterfinger pie on a white plate.
Butterfinger Pie | Cookies and Cups 59

Suggestions for Success

In the case of the most effective Butterfinger pie, listed here are some suggestions that make this recipe a breeze:

  • Use Retailer Purchased Crust: The pie crust recipe is tremendous easy. Nevertheless, if you happen to’re in a rush, a store-bought, ready-made graham cracker crust will just do nice for a 100% no-bake dessert.
  • Make the Crust In a Meals Processor: You probably have a blender or meals processor readily available, making the pie crust is that a lot simpler. Merely mix the crust elements within the processor and mix them along with a couple of fast pulses.
  • Warmth the Knife For Slicing: To maintain the pie from sticking to the knife once you slice it, heat the knife first. Run it beneath scorching water and wipe off the knife with a paper towel between slices to maintain the pie edges good and clear.
A forkful of Butterfinger pie on a white plate next to a pie slice.
Butterfinger Pie | Cookies and Cups 60

Variation Concepts

This Butterfinger pie is simply as simple to customise as it’s to make! Check out a number of of those yummy variation concepts:

  • Use Selfmade Whipped Cream: Cool Whip is a fuss-free shortcut to make use of within the pie filling. In fact, if you happen to’re whipping cream from scratch for the garnish, be happy to make further selfmade whipped cream to make use of within the filling as effectively. As talked about earlier, be certain that to make use of a calming steel bowl and chilly whipping cream for the most effective outcomes.
  • Use Completely different Sweet: Can’t get your fingers on Butterfingers? This peanut butter pie seems simply as tasty made with one other peanut butter sweet, like Reese’s Cups. Or, strive chopping up Snickers bars as an alternative! In case you’d favor to depart the sweet out altogether, you’ll be able to all the time add chopped peanuts as an alternative.
  • Use a Chocolate Crust: Typically, once I’m feeling further indulgent, I’ll borrow the chocolate Oreo pie crust from my Chocolate Candy Pie recipe!
  • Drizzle With Chocolate: For a fudgy twist, give your pie a drizzle of Pourable Chocolate Ganache. You may also strive it with Homemade Caramel Sauce!
  • Sprinkle With Sea Salt: Y’all know I really like the addition of sea salt in desserts like cookies and peanut brittle. Why not sprinkle the highest of this Butterfinger pie with sea salt for a scrumptious candy and salty combo?
  • Use Chunky Peanut Butter: I’m a fan of the ultra-smooth, mousse-y filling on this recipe. However if you happen to’re after one thing with extra crunch, go proper forward and use shelf-stable chunky peanut butter as an alternative!
  • Add Crushed Cookies: Take inspiration from my Nutter Butter Pie and toss in crushed peanut butter cookies! 
  • Use a Sq. Pan: Make no-bake Butterfinger pie bars in an 8×8-inch sq. baking dish. I like to recommend lining the pan with foil and giving it a coating of cooking spray beforehand.
A fork cuts into a slice of Butterfinger pie on a white plate.
Butterfinger Pie | Cookies and Cups 61

Storage Directions

Retailer your pie chilled within the fridge for as much as 3 days. Be sure to’re sealing your Butterfinger pie in an hermetic container or wrapping it tightly in plastic wrap to maintain the flavors intact.

Can I Freeze This?

In case you make your pie with Cool Whip, it may be frozen for as much as 1 month. Retailer the pie hermetic in a freezer-safe container, or wrap it tightly in plastic wrap. Let it sit out for a couple of minutes once you’re able to serve it, to melt it up once more.

Observe that Butterfinger pie that’s made with basic selfmade whipped cream, nevertheless, will not freeze effectively because the whipped cream might separate as soon as it’s thawed. 


clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfb fb iconprint print iconsquares squares iconcoronary heart coronary heart iconcoronary heart strong coronary heart strong icon


This creamy Butterfinger Pie is a straightforward dessert recipe loaded with Butterfinger sweet bars inside a creamy peanut butter pie filling.

For the Graham Cracker Crust

  • 2 cups graham cracker crumbs (about 15 full graham cracker sheets)
  • 1/2 cup butter, melted
  • 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1/3 cup granulated sugar

For the Pie Filling

  • 8 ounces cream cheese, room temperature
  • 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1/3 cup powdered sugar
  • 1 (11.5 ounce) bag Enjoyable Sized Butterfinger, chopped
  • 1 (8 ounce) tub Cool Whip, thawed

Garnish (optionally available)

  • 3/4 cup chilly heavy whipping cream
  • 2 tablespoons powdered sugar
  • 4 (Enjoyable Sized) Butterfinger sweet bars, chopped

Making the Graham Cracker Crust

  1. Preheat oven to 350°F/175°C
  2. Mix graham cracker crumbs, butter, salt and sugar in a bowl and stir to mix. Press the combination evenly within the backside and up the sizes of a 9- inch deep dish pie plate. Bake for 7-9 minutes till frivolously golden. Take away from the oven and permit the crust to chill utterly.

Making the Filling

  1. Within the bowl of the stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment combine collectively the cream cheese, peanut butter and powdered sugar for 1-2 minutes till evenly combined and {smooth}, scraping the edges of the bowl as mandatory. Add within the chopped Butterfinger and blend till mixed.
  2. Utilizing a rubber spatula or set the mixer to the bottom velocity, fold within the Cool Whip to the cream cheese combination till simply mixed. Unfold the combination into the ready crust and chill for a minimum of 2 hours.

Garnishing the Pie

  1. If desired if you end up able to serve the pie whip the heavy cream and the powdered sugar within the bowl of your stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment for 1-2 minutes till stiff peaks kind.
  2. Unfold this on prime of the pie and prime with the chopped Butterfinger.
  3. Serve instantly.


  • You should utilize selfmade whipped cream rather than the Cool Whip.
  • Retailer hermetic, chilled for as much as 3 days.
  • Vitamin information consists of garnish.


  • Serving Dimension:
  • Energy: 579
  • Sugar: 38.6 g
  • Sodium: 411 mg
  • Fats: 36.9 g
  • Carbohydrates: 58.5 g
  • Protein: 8 g
  • Ldl cholesterol: 57.8 mg

Key phrases: chocolate peanut butter pie, peanut butter pie, simple dessert recipe

Need To Save This Recipe?

Discover extra recipes like this:

Extra Simple Selfmade Pies to Strive

Trending Merchandise

Add to compare
Add to compare
Add to compare
Add to compare
Add to compare

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Shopping cart